More Details Other Editions 4. Friend Reviews. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. To ask other readers questions about War and Peace in Modern India , please sign up. Be the first to ask a question about War and Peace in Modern India. Lists with This Book.
For the longer term one of the choices the Indian elite should make is dramatically to improve the state of education in order to diminish, equally dramatically, poverty, injustice, inequality and, of course, illiteracy, hence possible violent social instability. Ellena Chua. He takes care not to contribute to escalation by mindless militarism. Departing from the usual tendency to indict Nehru on grounds of excessive caution or misplaced idealism, Raghavan argues that courses of action which appear to depart from a rational standard require an analysis of the political considerations at work 7. Final Price Rs.
Community Reviews. Showing Rating details. More filters. Sort order. Oct 17, Savyasachee rated it it was amazing Shelves: history , indian-history , politics. TL;DR: If you have any thoughts about Nehru and you want them substantiated by facts, read this book.
Military power is most impactful when it's latent. I'm mangling the quote, but the sentiment seems to set the tone of Jawaharlal Nehru's foreign policy. Srinath Raghavan's study of his handling of conflicts in independent India dives deep into the thought process which came out with such a unique foreign policy, and brings out nuances which seem to have been hitherto dismissed or, to give some cr TL;DR: If you have any thoughts about Nehru and you want them substantiated by facts, read this book.
Srinath Raghavan's study of his handling of conflicts in independent India dives deep into the thought process which came out with such a unique foreign policy, and brings out nuances which seem to have been hitherto dismissed or, to give some critics their due, merely missed. The author takes the reader through all the major crises Nehru faced during his seventeen year-long tenure as Prime Minister involving other countries, or in some cases, Indian princely states.
Junagarh, Hyderabad and Kashmir are all presented as case studies all linked with each other. While the first two are the subjects of a chapter each, Kashmir, due to its outsize importance, is mentioned in nearly every chapter and has two long chapters completely dedicated to it.
A forgotten crisis in Bengal, diffused ironically by the assassination of Pakistani Prime Minister Liaquat Khan gets another chapter, while the Sino-Indian war gets two. All the chapters are expertly written. Each one is extensively sourced, the footnotes have annotations, and viewpoints are presented properly. Justice is done to the opinions of everyone involved, whether they be British, Indian or Pakistani to the extent the sources vindicate them.
The chapters flow into each other in the case of chapters two to four, and the rest of them dovetail nicely into the next. The end result is a coherently written, cogent source of information about the Nehru years which both Nehru admirers and revanchists ought to read. Perhaps the only criticism I can lay upon it is that it seems to portray Nehru in a rather favourable light.
It would be rather interesting to see points of view other than the ones which support Nehru. What exactly was Jayprakash Narayan thinking during all this? Can we get a better idea about what was going on in the minds of the Pakistanis while all this was going on? Maybe get a bit more detail into the strategic interests and ruminations of the Chinese? Of course, these criticisms aren't enough to derail my enjoyment of the book itself, but they do remain in my mind.
Brilliant book which breaks the mold into which the legacy of Jawaharlal Nehru has been cast. Shelves: history , hard-copy , india , soft-copy. The thesis of this balanced and professionally written work is twofold. Second, there was consistency as well as continuity in Nehru's handling of foreign policy issues.
In both of these, the book succeeds and them some. I will take a moment to point, the book is not a hagiography. While the author doesn't opine on the matter mak The thesis of this balanced and professionally written work is twofold. While the author doesn't opine on the matter making it at cursory glance seem like one mid-read, a closing reading as well as the concluding notes make more than clear it is anything but. This is a remarkable first work by a historian and a valuable contribution. This book is an outstanding ethnography, well-contextualised, scholarly and clearly-written, but is likely to appeal mainly to specialists because of the density of its discussion.
It has implications for many areas of academic debate. This he proposes to do by using a selection of foreign policy crises which hit the newly independent Indian state in the s and early s, all involving territory, neighbours and hence, national security.
A study of Indian foreign policy under Jawaharlal Nehru, concentrating on the fundamental questions of war and peace. Looks at Nehru's handling of the disputes over the fate of Junagadh, Hyderabad and Kashmir in ; the refugee crisis in East and West Bengal in ; the. gepickrecboigluc.tk - Buy War and Peace in Modern India book online at best prices in India on gepickrecboigluc.tk Read War and Peace in Modern India book reviews & author .
Departing from the usual tendency to indict Nehru on grounds of excessive caution or misplaced idealism, Raghavan argues that courses of action which appear to depart from a rational standard require an analysis of the political considerations at work 7. By this the author is referring to the following set of possible forces: domestic concerns and constituencies, powerful external actors, normative standards of international behaviour and issues of reputation.
However, in his introduction no model of decision-making, policyselection or strategy-formulation is proposed, although the author does seek to distinguish between consensual, controlling and coercive strategies, with each making varying use of threats of force. Having laid bare a minimal conceptual and theoretical frame, chapter one presents a short intellectual background to Nehrus strategic outlook.
Some clues are provided of Raghavans analytical prism. For instance, when he writes that a core task of political leaders is to demonstrate the links between policies, interests, and values p. Unfortunately, the linkage between these three components is not overtly explored. Subsequent chapters are highly detailed and intricate in their observations about how Nehru viewed and responded to critical crises.
The cases of Junagadh, Hyderabad and Jammu and Kashmir are used to reveal the complications that arose from the issue of accession to the Indian Union in The refugee inux and instability within Pakistan provoked numerous occasions of tension and the need for urgent, rm and delicate diplomacy. Chapters seven and eight are devoted to yet another scale of crisis: the boundary dispute with China and the run-up to the SinoIndian war of OctoberNovember Here perhaps there could have been more analysis of the Panchasheel Agreement between India and China, the contents and its implications.
War and peace in modern India is a polished historical study, making extensive and thorough use of archival material in India and the United Kingdom, drawing upon both private papers and open sources such as newspapers and periodicals from the time. It is also an unusual work, in that the author claims as a main goal the need to uncover patterns and options of strategic behaviour which emerged during this crucial phase and which continue to be relevant for contemporary India.
This dimension of the book is particularly important given on-going discussions about Nehrus legacy and the controversies this generates. However, here is where the book suers slightly, for one misses a clear hypothesis relating to policy-making the processes involved, the importance of individuals versus structures and institutions that could have provided an organizing framework to the dense empirical chapters.
Perhaps because of this the concluding chapter is rather brief. Nevertheless, Raghavans coverage of early foreign policy crises will be of great use to teachers and students of Indian foreign policy, especially as not so much is available on the Junagadh and Hyderabad issues of accession and particularly not linking the various responses to crises.
The s in Indias political development remains a wellspring of information and insight into the dynamics of institution building and the learning process that leaders were going through during phases of crisis-management.
Singh, New Delhi, Sage, , xx pp. Read Free For 30 Days. Description: Review of Srinath Raghavan's book. Flag for inappropriate content.
From Gandhi's early support of Britain's war efforts to the crucial Burma Campaign, Raghavan's authoritative and vivid account shows how India's economy, politics and people were forever transformed, laying the groundwork for the emergence of modern South Asia. Featured Book No other form of art can capture the range and diversity of human experience the way a poem can. Read More. Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube Blog. Overview Between and India underwent an extraordinary and irreversible change.